The Liontrust UK Growth Fund returned -3.4%* in January. The FTSE All-Share Index comparator benchmark returned -0.3% and the average return in the IA UK All Companies sector, also a comparator benchmark, was -3.7%.
The -0.3% index return looks fairly innocuous, but beneath this headline number lay a number of influential trends which help explain the Fund and IA sector’s underperformance.
Chief among these influences was a sharp rise in interest rate expectations. Concerns over inflationary pressures and the monetary policy response were a feature of 2021, but central banks were largely happy to take a wait-and-see approach. In January, statements from the US Federal Reserve delivered a strong message that quantitative easing would finish in March, with US interest rates also likely to be raised in the same month and continue to be hiked through 2022 at a faster rate than had been anticipated.
As well as driving up bond yields (US and UK two year government bond yields both rose around 30bps to 1.1% and 1.0% respectively), the prospect of higher interest rates prompted a sharp equity market rotation away from ‘growth’ stocks – which suffer from higher discount rates applied to their future forecast earnings – and towards ‘value’ stocks, which, by contrast, are viewed as short-duration assets less affected by discount rates.
The rotation shows up dramatically in MSCI index data: the UK value series outperformed its growth equivalent by 12 percentage points in January alone.
The Economic Advantage investment process applied to this Fund is a bottom-up, stock-picking process. We do not set out to achieve any style or size bias outcomes within the Fund. But because the process seeks out dependable, consistent businesses with barriers to competition, high financial returns and strong balance sheets, there is an observable style footprint that emerges: a tilt towards ‘quality’ and away from value. The investment process doesn’t actively target companies with high forecast EPS (earnings per share) growth, but this often goes hand-in-hand with the characteristics it does seek, such as high cash flow return on capital; this is particularly true of the Fund’s smaller companies.
In a stark risk-off environment, there was also a size bias to equity market returns; while the FTSE 100 index made a positive 1.1% return, the mid-cap FTSE 250 lost 6.5% and the FTSE Small Cap returned -3.9%. The FTSE AIM All Share Index fared even worse, losing 10%.
As well as having a pro-quality and anti-value tilt, the Fund also has a bias away from the FTSE 100 and towards mid and small caps. The Fund has 59% exposure to the FTSE 100 – below its 80% weight in the FTSE All-Share – with 29% in FTSE 250 stocks, 3% in FTSE Small Caps and 7% in AIM stocks.
Over the last few years, the Fund’s style and size profile has been a tailwind to performance, particularly during the recovery from the initial Covid-19 sell-off in early 2020. Not surprisingly, many of the stocks and funds – including Liontrust UK Growth – that were resilient and outperformed last year, suffered a reversal in January as tailwinds became headwinds: small underperformed large and growth underperformed value.
Given the month presented a near ‘perfect storm’ of headwinds, the scale of the Fund’s underperformance during the month wasn’t too discouraging.
Overlying all of this discussion of style factors is of course the fundamental truth that we are bottom-up stockpickers, and every stock is to some degree a mixture of many different style sub-factors- sometimes even 'value' and 'growth' and 'quality ' at the same time.
So, in January, the better portfolio performers included those with at least one foot in the value camp. This included the likes of British American Tobacco (+16%), WH Smith (+11%), BAE Systems (+5.0%) and the oil & gas sector stocks – Shell (+17%), BP (+16%) and John Wood Group (+16%) – which benefitted from a 17% rally in the oil price (and a positive trading update in John Wood Group’s case.
While there was also positive newsflow for WH Smith in the form of a trading update showing further steady recovery in retail volumes, these positive share price moves were the result of the investor style rotation we have described.
This is all the more apparent among the main detractors, many of which have good cash flow returns on capital and high share valuations. None of Halma (-22%), RWS Holdings (-21%), Rightmove (-17%) or Domino’s Pizza Group (-16%) issued significant newsflow in January. Spirax-Sarco Engineering (-17%) announced only a relatively small acquisition.
In our experience, January often sees an automatic reversal of the trends that worked well the previous year. On this occasion, it’s very hard to predict whether these headwinds will persist or ease. Our investment process explicitly excludes any form of macroeconomic forecasting in favour of pursuing the bottom-up approach that has served us so well over the years.
While the equity market narrative around rising inflation and interest rates currently centres on the value versus growth debate, it may well develop to incorporate more nuanced factors, such as which companies possess the pricing power to maintain margins within an inflationary environment. One of the fundamental characteristics we look for in companies we invest in is a durable competitive advantage which confers a high degree of pricing power. A company with true pricing power can pass on some or all cost inflation rather than having to absorb it through a reduction in profit margins.
The evidence so far is that our companies are coping well in the current environment. Overall, we’ve found that trading updates across the portfolio continue to be positive, with expectations being met or exceeded. We have seen some caution in outlook statements, as companies continue to draw attention to global political and economic uncertainties which are out of their control, such as supply chain problems.
While the Fund’s style, size and sector footprint were all unhelpful in January, it performed exactly as we would expect it to given the prevailing conditions. Over the long term, the consistent application of our investment process has yielded very good returns. Even if the market correction has further to go, we have high conviction in our stocks and every reason to believe they will continue to add value over the long run.
Positive contributors included:
Shell (+17%), BP (+16%), John Wood Group (+16%), British American Tobacco (+16%) and WH Smith (+11%).
Negative contributors included:
Halma (-22%), RWS Holdings (-21%), Rightmove (-18%), Spirax-Sarco Engineering (-17%) and Domino’s Pizza Group (-16%).
Discrete years' performance** (%), to previous quarter-end:
Dec-21 |
Dec-20 |
Dec-19 |
Dec-18 |
Dec-17 |
|
Liontrust UK Growth I Inc |
21.0% |
-8.3% |
19.9% |
-6.1% |
14.2% |
FTSE All Share |
18.3% |
-9.8% |
19.2% |
-9.5% |
13.1% |
IA UK All Companies |
17.2% |
-6.0% |
22.2% |
-11.2% |
14.0% |
Quartile |
1 |
3 |
3 |
1 |
2 |
*Source: Financial Express, as at 31.01.22, total return (net of fees and income reinvested), bid-to-bid, institutional class.
**Source: Financial Express, as at 31.12.21, total return (net of fees and income reinvested), bid-to-bid, primary class.
Key Risks